November 20, 2026 · 8 min read · Chandler Saine

Most Wholesalers Kill Their Deals on the First Offer

If your team keeps getting squeezed on price, my first assumption is not that the sellers are impossible. It's that your first offer is a little too high.

That sounds backwards if you've been taught to "come in close so you don't lose them." It isn't. Sellers are going to negotiate anyway. If you start too high, the number you finally agree on is higher than you wanted, your spread shrinks, and now you're stuck deciding whether to swing the bat for a thin fee or walk.

I walked through this with a team that was feeling exactly that pinch. You can watch the full conversation here:

Why a high first offer quietly kills the deal

For us, when we underwrite a cash deal, we start with about $100,000 of profit. That's the starting asking price, not the prayer number at the end. Then we move up — often $20k to $30k into a novation — and we can move up from there if the situation calls for it.

The team I was talking to had been anchoring cash around 45% to 50% of ARV and wanting about a $50k spread on novation. In practice, they were finding it easier and easier to go up in price. Their novation fees were coming in around $10k to $20k. A $30k-plus fee had become rare. Some of their guys were just afraid of friction. The sellers were stubborn, and the team kept getting walked up.

If that's happening to you, you're not crazy. You're getting squeezed because you left yourself no room, and because you never anchored the conversation low enough for the later options to feel like a win.

Always make the cash offer, even to a novation seller

Everyone who clicked on your ad wants a cash offer. That's why they're there. A lot of sellers have also already heard a novation pitch, so that offer is not as new as it used to be.

What we do is still make a cash offer to everyone. Sometimes we just frame it differently:

This is a two-week close. This is $5,000 in earnest money. Diligence is short. If you want to go the cash route and do it fast, this is what that looks like. We also have ways we can pay you more.

We always present it. That way they can see how much lower cash is, and it anchors the conversation. If they want $400k, you might now be talking around $200k — and talking about why that number does or doesn't work — instead of starting the whole negotiation up at their number.

I 100% agree there are sellers where cash is never going to work. Give them the cash offer anyway. Then you have somewhere to go.

About a quarter of the time, we'll sign a 60-day novation with a cash offer sitting behind it, because the seller still wants to feel like every dollar is getting in their pocket.

Stack three options so your "middle" offer can stay lower

Here's the structure we've been using.

Option 1: Cash. Fast close, heavy anchor, not the path most people take, but it sets the floor.

Option 2: Novation. This is the middle. We're trying to make about $50,000. We can sell it in 60 days, and we're not planning to retrade. Cash is the backup. Because we have a higher third option, this number can sit a lot lower than it would if novation was your "max dollar" pitch.

Option 3: The service-fee / 90-day option. This is for the seller who wants max dollar. We still anchor them on what a realistic listing outcome looks like. Then we say: in the next 3 to 4 weeks, we'll bring you three of the highest retail offers the market will give you. We'll negotiate them up, we'll present them to you, and you pick the best one. It's not me inventing a price. It's the market telling you what it's willing to pay.

We give them a range — something like a $30k band — and we're clear that all we charge is a fee. In the conversation I used $20,000 as the example. Now your profit is fixed. The risk is that some people don't treat it like a serious contract, so we've been putting in a $3,000 termination fee and being very direct: after you sign, our team is investing real time and money to market this. This is an engaged, legally binding agreement.

That third option is what lets the cash number and the novation number stay lower, because the seller still has a path to max market value.

Educate them on the reality of the house, don't just "go low"

Price work is not "we have to be lower." It's "here's the reality of this house."

If a seller tells you their mom's bed is in the living room, you don't ignore it to keep the call comfortable. You ask: if we market this to retail buyers, do you understand what that's going to look like when they walk through? Do you think that's going to help you or hurt you? They already know the answer. You've just said it out loud.

We do hundreds of deals. At the end of the day I want them to work with someone who can actually perform on the other side. When you uncover those details and use them to educate the seller, you can still get to a realistic number without making it a fight for no reason.

If you're going to swing at a high number, pick the right seller

There isn't one perfect answer on stubborn sellers. Our stance is we do our absolute best to get them to a realistic number — and that's for the seller's benefit, so they actually get what they want, not a fantasy that falls apart in diligence.

I also know someone out there will quote them the number they asked for. I feel confident we can get more money in their pocket than anyone else who will actually perform. You still have to choose which of those stubborn sellers you contract with.

A deal in Richmond is the perfect example. Our cash offer was about $220k, which I think was right. The novation was around $260k. She wanted about $370k, maybe $375k. The house had foundation and septic issues. But her motivation was high, and her timeline was real — about 90 to 100 days.

We locked it up anyway, with the right expectations. We weren't selling a guaranteed price. We were selling guaranteed highest market-value offers. We'd get her the best market offers in the next three to four weeks and let the market speak.

We ended up getting a price reduction to $250k — a $125,000 reduction from that $375k ask — because she had to sell, and she needed to know she wasn't leaving money on the table. That's the root cause for a lot of stubborn sellers. It's not always greed. It's fear of getting taken.

Mid-contract we also found out she thought she needed $200,000 down on the next house. Her credit was around 570, and she'd been told it needed to be 580 to qualify. I connected her with a loan officer I trust. He could work on the credit and get her to a normal 20% down payment — about $80k on the same house. The second she learned that, the number she "had to have" changed.

Buyers walked it. One came back with $100,000 in repairs. We were getting offers in the low $300s that probably needed around $20,000 of credit, so you're looking at something like a $280k to $290k net. That's a $20k to $30k deal — but only because we now had a realistic seller.

Two takeaways:

  1. Offer lower.
  2. If you're going to take a shot at a high number, do it with someone who has a real deadline and real motivation.

I'll lock up a seller with a deadline at almost any price as long as the expectations are good. We may need to be lower, but we'll try. The combo I want is equity, a timeline, and no financial means to just sit there. Plus a clear service: not a guaranteed price, the guaranteed highest market offers.

Friction is for the seller, not for your ego

A lot of salespeople are afraid of friction. I want the opposite. I don't want anyone lying, but if I'm going to lean, I want people who will go all out to get the deal — and who I sometimes have to reel back — not people who are scared to do the deal.

The reframe for your team is this: you are creating friction because you are the best option that seller has. There are plenty of people who will drag a seller out or screw the deal up. You're going to be transparent, tell the truth, and do things other companies won't do to get them to the closing table.

I'm not creating friction to create friction. I'm creating friction because I know it's going to be best for them. I wouldn't argue with someone I didn't care about. I'd just let it go.

And stop the victim mentality in the sales meeting. If you played baseball and you failed 70% of the time, you'd be a Hall of Famer. In this business you're going to talk to 99 people to get the one or two who actually want to do the deal. Focus on those people. The other 99 don't help you.

What to change on the next call

Start your offers lower. Give every seller a cash offer so you have an anchor. Build a middle option and a max-dollar service option so you're not using novation as your only "more money" lever. If you take a high-number shot, take it with timeline and motivation, and sell the process, not a fantasy price.

If you want the systems, offer structure, and sales coaching behind this, that's what we build at Level Up REI. Apply to work with us here, or go deeper on coaching.

Watch the full walkthrough in the video above — including the Richmond deal and how we frame the three options on the call.

If you want to see how we would run your ads

Apply to Work With Us